Melton Hill Musky Fishing: Top Q&A for 2025
Melton Hill musky fishing is a challenge worth mastering in 2025. This moody Tennessee reservoir confounds even seasoned anglers with its unpredictable nature. On its best days, Melton Hill is a calm, stable lake anyone can figure out quickly—but those days are rare. Unlike typical lakes where weather and seasonality suffice, Melton Hill demands attention to dam releases (up and downstream), current flow, and water clarity. Yet, even a solid plan accounting for the dams isn’t enough—unique factors here keep you guessing.
As a Tennessee musky guide with countless hours on Melton Hill, I’m still learning its secrets daily. Keep an open mind to its lessons. This 2025 Q&A guide answers the most common questions about Melton Hill musky fishing, from native populations to the best lures, to help you succeed.
Summary of Melton Hill Musky Fishing Q&A
Musky are native to Tennessee, likely pre-dam in Melton Hill.
No official natural reproduction, but some likely occurs.
Size limit: 50 inches; keep musky alive for conservation.
Best spots: Norris Dam base, Hope Creek, Clark Center Park.
Top lures: Titan, Medussa, Steve’s Meat Grinder, and more.
Peak seasons: Dec-Feb (feed bag) and May-June (post-spawn).
Are Musky Native to Tennessee?
Yes, musky are native to Tennessee. Historically, they thrived in rivers like the Powell and Clinch. Over decades, stocking efforts by the TWRA have rebuilt populations in waters hit by industrialization, pollution, and habitat loss. Today, Tennessee musky fishing thrives thanks to these efforts.
Are Musky Native to Melton Hill?
Officially, no—but logic suggests yes. The Powell River, a native musky waterway in East Tennessee, flows into Norris Lake, which then feeds Melton Hill. Before Norris Dam’s construction in the 1930s, the Powell and Clinch Rivers were directly connected. Native musky likely swam into what’s now Melton Hill. Did they survive the dam-building era’s environmental shifts? Without a time machine, we can’t say for sure—but their presence predates modern boundaries.
Is There Natural Musky Reproduction on Melton Hill?
Musky spawn on Melton Hill, but the official answer is no—natural reproduction isn’t confirmed. TWRA biologists base this on data, not anecdotal reports. Yet, Great Falls was once in the same boat before being recognized as a natural reproduction system. As a guide spending too much time on Melton Hill, I’d bet my boat some limited reproduction happens here—small-scale, but real.
What Is the Size Limit for Melton Hill Musky?
The size limit for keeping a musky on Melton Hill is 50 inches. This strict rule ensures it remains a trophy-class fishery. Only the biggest fish qualify, protecting the population’s health.
Can You Keep a Musky?
No, musky anglers shouldn’t keep them—even those over 50 inches. Musky have no table value; eating them is pointless. Skin mounts are outdated—modern replica mounts look better, last longer, and cost less. Killing even one musky harms the fishery. These slow, fragile reproducers need careful handling to thrive.
Where to Find Musky on Melton Hill?
Musky roam from the base of Norris Dam to the Melton Hill Dam face. They’ve settled throughout the system, in shallow and deep waters alike, including connecting creeks and streams. Start your pursuit at:
Hope Creek: Target drop-offs with glide baits.
Clark Center Park: Fish shallow edges near structure.
Look for current breaks and weed lines—they’re musky magnets.
What Are the Best Lures for Melton Hill Musky Fishing?
Here are the top 10 Melton Hill musky lures (in no order—seasonality dictates their shine):
Livingston Lures Titan: Adjustable weights for winter versatility.
Livingston Lures Magnus: Big profile for trophy hunters.
Figure 8 Lure Co. Steve’s Meat Grinder: Deadly in murky water.
Chaos Tackle Medussa: Erratic action triggers strikes.
Kamakaze Chatter Bait: Vibration for active fish.
Joe Bucher Topraider: Classic topwater for summer.
Shallow Invader: Perfect for post-spawn shallows.
Figure 8 Lure Co. Steve’s Tailgaiter: Subtle tail action shines.
Shum Shum Glide Bait: Smooth glides for followers.
Slammer Tackle 7” Minnow: Mimics abundant baitfish.
What Is the Best Time to Fish for Musky on Melton Hill?
Melton Hill musky fishing peaks twice:
December-February (Feed Bag): Musky bulk up for winter and spawn, chasing big prey like walleye, suckers, and skipjack. Slow, deep lures work best.
May-June (Post-Spawn): After spawning, musky spread out, hitting peak metabolism. Use shallow lures and fast retrieves—they’re hungry and aggressive.
Are Melton Hill Musky Eating All the Other Fish?
No, musky aren’t depleting sport fish populations. Their numbers are low, and they don’t eat often—a medium fish sustains them for days as they rest in the depths. They prefer abundant, easy prey like suckers, skipjack, shad, and small carp over crappie or walleye. Melton Hill’s rough fish buffet keeps musky satisfied without harm.
What Equipment Do I Need for Melton Hill Musky Fishing?
Melton Hill musky fishing requires:
Steel Leader: Prevents bite-offs and ensures safe releases.
80-lb Test Braided Line: Handles big fish and structure.
Heavy Duty Casting Rod: For power and control.
High-Quality Reel: Smooth drag for long fights.
This gear matches any musky water—safety and success depend on it.
Final Tips for Melton Hill Musky Fishing
Study dam schedules—current drives fish behavior.
Use polarized sunglasses to spot shallow musky.
Handle fish gently; wet hands and quick releases matter.
Experiment with lures—Melton Hill rewards adaptability.
Book a guide (like me!) to shortcut the learning curve.
New anglers: Learn not just how to catch musky, but how to release them safely. They’re a finite resource worth protecting.
Steven Paul,
Tennessee Musky
Commentaires